Hanna LUZE 医师
整形外科医师
其他作者: Sebastian P. Nischwitz, Lars-Peter Kamolz, Thomas Rappl
Autologous vs alloplastic breast reconstruction – Differences in complication rates and long-term satisfaction
Objectives: High oncological safety as well as patient satisfaction regarding the aesthetic-functional result is of utmost importance in modern breast cancer management. For breast reconstruction after mastectomy, alloplastic alternatives with silicone implants are available in addition to various autologous reconstruction options such as free flaps or autologous fat grafting. The present study aimed to generate valuable data to aid in preoperative decision-making and generate the best result for each patient individually.
Introduction: Previous studies have focused on the possible complications of the techniques in detail, but there have been no conclusive comparative studies to date. In addition, existing data from isolated studies on the quality of life, satisfaction, psychosocial and physical well-being of patients who underwent breast reconstruction after breast cancer is inconclusive and not comparable.
Materials / method: In the course of a multicenter retrospective data analysis, complication types and rates as well as several other patient- and surgery related factors were evaluated in free tissue transfer (deep inferior epigastric artery perforator flap, transverse rectus abdominis myocutaneous flap, or latissimus flap), and the use of implants or tissue expanders for breast reconstruction after carcinoma therapy. Standardized Breast-Q questionnaires were used to analyze quality of life, satisfaction, psychosocial and physical well-being in different techniques.
Results: Within the study collective, significant differences regarding the complication types and rates as well as potential risk factors were found and will be discussed together with the results of the current literature. Despite higher complication rates and number of revision surgeries, the long-term satisfaction was shown to be significantly higher in patients who underwent autologous breast reconstruction.
Conclusion: Significant differences in complication types and rates as well as long-term satisfaction were shown in different reconstruction techniques. Findings of these study may aid in preoperative decision-making along with patient-related factors, in order to generate the best result for each patient individually.